Tuesday 23 Apr 2024
By
main news image

This article first appeared in The Edge Malaysia Weekly on July 18, 2022 - July 24, 2022

WHILE stating that the worst is yet to come in terms of inflation, with no end in sight, Dutch Lady Milk Industries Bhd managing director Ramjeet Kaur Virik is “cautiously optimistic” that the company will be able to manage the shocks.

The timing of her taking office about a year ago could have been better in view of the challenges on the horizon. Ramjeet has her work cut out for her. On top of these looming challenges, the dairy product maker has embarked on a RM400 million expansion plan to build a new production facility at a time when commodity prices, including those of building materials, are escalating.

“This is unprecedented,” she tells The Edge, referring to the current economic scenario. “Nobody has ever seen this kind of global inflationary pressure before. The amount of inflation and the cost of doing business is a lot higher.

“So, we already know what is coming until the end of the year and, if I can say, the worst is yet to come; the third quarter is going to be the peak. We are hopeful, though. It seems to be levelling off, but it is not coming down. So, it is going to stay at the high.

“As long as it does not continue to increase, that is one hope we have, and one way we can manage it is to try to optimise cost everywhere,” Ramjeet says.

The global supply chain disruption had resulted in the dairy group’s opting to use air freight to bring in the raw materials needed to ensure production lines continued to run. Ramjeet did not disclose the impact of cost increase on the company.

“The supply chain disruption is very much related to the global container [shortage]; this has been happening since the pandemic started and I think made worse by the China lockdown. Fortunately, the Shanghai port is now open — it is one of the top ports in the world — but the [Russia-Ukraine] war is also not helping and continues to cause that disruption.”

Apart from the disruption in sourcing raw material, Ramjeet says logistics also experienced a disruption in the shipment of Dutch Lady products from Peninsular Malaysia to Sabah and Sarawak, but the company has managed to solve it.

“When you go to the supermarket and sometimes you may see empty shelves, it is a reflection of challenges on the retailers’ side, where they have to make sure that the products are available despite a disruption,” she says.

Dutch Lady has not managed to escape cost inflation, but the saving grace is perhaps that demand appears to be relatively inelastic despite several rounds of price hikes to cope with higher raw material costs.

According to the Global Dairy Trade website, the price of skim milk powder has increased 37% year on year to US$4,063 a tonne on July 5, while the price of whole milk powder has risen 6% in the same period to US$3,961 a tonne.

Dutch Lady’s annual profit margin swelled, however, to 21.87% as at Dec 31, 2021 (FY2021), mainly lifted by a one-off gain from land sales. For FY2020, its profit margin was 6.67%, on the back of a net profit of RM73.36 million and revenue of RM1.1 billion.

For the first quarter ended March 31, 2022 (1QFY2022), its net profit margin returned to single digits of 6.86%, given its net profit of RM20.57 million on revenue of RM299.87 million.

“What we focus on is to ensure we continue to supply, and as long as we can continue to secure a top line, I think we will manage our bottom line. That is how we have been managing the business in the last two years,” she says.

According to her, consumer demand has been encouraging for the past six months and the reopening of schools further helps drive demand and milk consumption.

“We are optimistic that demand will continue because of the awareness of the importance of nutrition. And we have a huge role to play in the country’s development for the future [in the nutritional standards of Malaysians]. So, that is where the optimism comes from.

“The cautiousness is the cost. So, we need to save money everywhere [by cost optimisation] and we cannot just raise the price; that is not how to drive penetration [of milk] because that is counterintuitive in a sense,” Ramjeet says.

She stresses that Dutch Lady has been reviewing its pricing strategy monthly while trying to ensure the affordability of its products.

The dairy company’s net profit for 1QFY2022 grew nearly 22% year on year (y-o-y) to RM20.57 million, from RM16.88 million, owing to a recovery in economic activities from the relaxation of the lockdown, high demand as well as price hikes to offset strong inflationary headwinds.

Quarterly revenue increased 16% y-o-y to RM299.87 million from RM258.64 million. Earnings per share expanded to 32.1 sen, from 26.4 sen previously.

The company recorded a good performance for its financial year ended Dec 31, 2021 (FY2021) as net profit soared 238% y-o-y to RM248 million from RM73.36 million. Its annual earnings were boosted by the one-off land sale gain of RM154.7 million before its relocation, along with 3% revenue growth to RM1.13 billion, from RM1.1 billion in FY2020.

“We [have seen] a good revenue increase, but that is also because of price increases that we had to do in the market. We are confident about driving the penetration of milk in Malaysia because we know milk is a nutritious product.

“As long the trend continues, I think the top line will be fine. We will be able to fulfil our ambitions. Profit is still a challenge, however, as the cost of doing business has increased,” Ramjeet says.

Ramjeet says the long awaited Industry 4.0 (IR4.0)-compliant factory in Bandar Enstek, Negeri Sembilan, to be built via internally generated funds, aims to run commercially in 2024, with a target to double its current manufacturing capacity by then.

The factory will be equipped with advanced technologies, including automation, big data, cloud computing and the Internet of Things to increase its production efficiency.

“IR4.0 would ensure there is no disruption in operations and, when your efficiency goes up, your conversion cost goes down; then your margins go up. That is the part that I am looking forward to.

“And it is about traceability. Because we are a food company, we want to know which product, line or source whose data we can use for the traceability of our product,” Ramjeet says.

With ongoing inflation, she says, the new factory has gone beyond its budgeted RM400 million, but it has locked in almost all of its tenders to keep the budget in check.

Its facility in Malaysia, which exports to Singapore and Brunei, has reached its maximum capacity.

“We have run out of space and capacity; we are looking forward to being a hub for the region and being in the halal hub. We know the global halal industry is set to continue to grow in the coming years, so we have earmarked it, and the location is also perfect as a hub for the region,” Ramjeet says.

According to Dutch Lady’s 2021 annual report, the new facility is situated in a 13.35ha industrial park, and is triple the size of its existing factory.Ramjeet says data has shown that the Malaysian halal dairy market is valued at RM4 billion and milk consumption per capita in the country is about 11 litres compared with 40 litres in developed countries such as in Europe.

 

Illiquid shares, margin compression make Dutch Lady less appealing

Despite having a much cheaper valuation than its peer Farm Fresh Bhd, Dutch Lady Milk Industries Bhd is not on the radar of many analysts.

Dutch Lady is trading at a forward price-earnings ratio (PER) of 22.67 times, based on its share price of RM33.10 on Thursday (July 14), compared to its rival Farm Fresh Bhd’s PER of 31.54 times, based on its share price of RM1.64.

Of the two brokerage houses tracking Dutch Lady, BIMB Securities Research has turned cautious after it downgraded its call on July 1 to a “hold” from a “buy” previously, with a lower target price of RM33.70, down from RM41.30. Kenanga Research kept its “market perform” call, but raised its target price to RM35.60, from RM34.75, in May.

Meanwhile, Farm Fresh — which was listed on March 22 — is on the buying list of eight analysts.

Margin pressures from rising raw material prices and the illiquidity of the stock are the major reasons analysts are shunning Dutch Lady despite its relative attractive valuations.

On top of that, the dairy firm’s dividend payment has been on decline for the past four years.  From 280 sen dividend a share in FY2017, it shrank to 200 sen in FY2018, 100 sen in FY2019, 80 sen in FY2020 and 50 sen in FY2021.

These factors may explain the downtrend on its share price.

In a recent interview, Dutch Lady managing director Ramjeet Kaur Virik explains that the rationale for a lower dividend is to conserve cash for the group’s RM400 million expansion plan to build new facilities in Negeri Sembilan.

An analyst who requested anonymity tells The Edge: “Dutch Lady’s raw material for its product is milk powder and it has to import it. Given rising raw material costs, the company is facing a margin squeeze. Also, it appears to be losing market share.

“Farm Fresh sources its raw material from the fresh milk produced by its own dairy cattle. As such, the company is able to expand its margin and grow its market share.”

Rakuten Trade Sdn Bhd vice-president of equity research Thong Pak Leng tells The Edge that the illiquidity of Dutch Lady’s stock is less appealing. Like some foreign-owned companies, Thong says, the major shareholders have a tight grip on the shares.

Dutch Lady has an issued share capital of 64 million shares. Its controlling shareholder FrieslandCampina DLMI Malaysia Holdings BV owns a 50.96% stake, while the Employees Provident Fund holds an 11.08% stake, and Amanahraya Trustee Bhd has a 7.62% stake.

“We will review it [illiquidity] in a board meeting, whether it’s going for public funding or private funding or privatisation or whatever you call it. Those are options that are always available to us. In that sense, the reputation of the company is also quite stable; so, that helps us a lot,” says Ramjeet.

Kenanga Research analyst Ahmad Ramzani Ramli highlights that the outlook remains challenging for Dutch Lady in the immediate term, as global dairy prices are expected to be on an uptrend into 2023.

“With its focus to provide nourishment to Malaysians at affordable prices, we believe Dutch Lady would be prudent with any price hikes, which could be insufficient to offset the elevated commodity costs. We expect gross profit margins to be constant around this current level, given its strategic move to front-load its inventories to combat inflationary and unfavourable currency headwinds,” Ahmad Ramzani says in a report dated May 25.

According to the Global Dairy Trade website, the price of skim milk powder has increased 37% year on year to US$4,063 a tonne on July 5, and the price of whole milk powder has risen 6% in the same period to US$3,961 a tonne.

At 33.96%, Dutch Lady’s gross profit margin for the first quarter ended March 31, 2022 (1QFY2022), has remained almost unchanged from 33.62% a year ago. Its net profit margin was 6.86% in 1QFY2022 — given its net profit of RM20.57 million with a revenue of RM299.87 million — compared to 6.53% in 1QFY2021, on the back of RM16.88 million and a revenue of RM258.64 million . — By Justin Lim

 

Save by subscribing to us for your print and/or digital copy.

P/S: The Edge is also available on Apple's AppStore and Androids' Google Play.

      Print
      Text Size
      Share