Thursday 28 Mar 2024
By
main news image

This article first appeared in The Edge Malaysia Weekly on August 28, 2017 - September 3, 2017

INVESTORS want clarity on AMMB Holdings Bhd’s (AmBank) future after the calling off of its proposed merger with RHB Bank Bhd, especially since its major shareholder Australia and New Zealand Banking Group (ANZ) intends to sell its stake, say fund managers and head of research houses.

“With this major shareholder wanting to divest and no takers, the road map ahead and future direction are not that clear. As long as there is no clarity on their (AmBank’s) strategy and what ANZ is going to do, investors will not be willing to pay a premium or ascribe to it a valuation that is at par to the industry’s,” Rakuten Trade Sdn Bhd head of research Kenny Yee tells The Edge.

AmBank, Affin Holdings Bhd and RHB Bank are the only banks listed on Bursa Malaysia that are trading below one times its book value at the moment. RHB Bank’s shares, however, have been on an upward trend since news of a possible delay in the merger talks emerged.

A fund manager who wants to remain anonymous tells The Edge that there should be a reversion for both banks as their share prices have been on the decline since May.

“RHB Bank has rebounded after the announcement that the merger is off. AmBank has other issues as ANZ wants [to make] an exit but there are no takers … it has created some uncertainty among investors. The news of the contingent liability that is apparently linked to 1MDB (1Malaysia Development Bhd) also created a bit of fear in the market,” he says.

“If you look at its price-to-book or even in terms of its latest earnings, I think AmBank has been oversold as a result of the uncertainties. But investors want clarity. So, they (AmBank) need to tell us what the situation with ANZ is and deny the link with 1MDB.”

It is worth noting that AmBank group CEO Datuk Sulaiman Mohd Tahir has refuted the existence of contingent liabilities linked to 1MDB in an exclusive interview with The Edge (see main story).

Nonetheless, the fund manager points out that in AmBank’s case, the recent selldown gives investors an opportunity to buy in, but he agrees that investors need more clarity before they make their move.

Inter-Pacific Research Sdn Bhd head of research Pong Teng Siew says the failure of the merger talks was not unexpected given the problems the banks had in arriving at a satisfactory valuation.

He believes that investors will stay on the sidelines, as reflected in AmBank’s share price movement. “The big anticipation has always been [for] a merger and acquisition. Without that, I think investors will just take a back seat for a while.”

He highlights the fact that AmBank’s share price had crept higher since the end of March, when The Edge reported a possible merger between the two banks.

AmBank’s share price rose 20.9% from RM4.53 at the end of March to a one-year high of RM5.48 on May 2.

Year to date, AmBank and RHB Bank have posted total returns — including dividends — of 5.44% and 9.45% respectively. In comparison, their Malaysian counterparts have an average total return of 14.86%. CIMB Group Holdings Bhd and Malayan Banking Bhd have the highest at 52.22% and 20.6% respectively while BIMB Holdings Bhd and Alliance Financial Group Bhd underperformed AmBank, with total returns of 4.27% and 4.86% respectively.

Since the termination of the merger talks, analysts have updated their reports, saying that it is back to the status quo for both banks.

Bloomberg data shows that out of the 19 analysts covering AmBank, eight gave it a “buy” call while eight recommended a “hold”. Only three of the analysts had a “sell” call. They have set an average 12-month target price for AmBank at RM4.81, representing a potential return of 8.6%.

As for RHB Bank, seven of the 18 analysts covering it gave it a “buy” call, nine had a neutral stance and the remaining two recommended a “sell”. Their 12-month average target price for RHB Bank is RM5.36, indicating an upside potential of 5.3% from its closing price of RM5.09 last Friday.

JP Morgan Asia Pacific Equity Research says the lack of consolidation is a net negative for the industry’s profitability in the medium term. “In the near term, we expect Maybank, CIMB, Public Bank and Hong Leong Bank to gain market share at the expense of RHB Bank and AmBank as both entities would have been focused on the execution of the merger,” its analyst, Harsh Wardhan Modi, says in a Aug 23 report. “With the deal being called off, it is likely that the two players will come back into the market with renewed drive, focused on price competition on both sides of the balance sheet.”

AmBank and RHB Bank closed at RM4.43 and RM5.09 respectively last Friday.

 

 

Save by subscribing to us for your print and/or digital copy.

P/S: The Edge is also available on Apple's AppStore and Androids' Google Play.

      Print
      Text Size
      Share